Montrail Rogue Racer Review

In years past, I’ve had bad experiences with Montrail shoes. Heavy, stiff, clunky ankle twisters come to mind. As other brands have undergone renewed success selling lighter more flexible shoes, Montrail in an effort to stay competitive now offer some lighter higher performance shoes of their own.

Montrail Rogue Racer

Montrail Rogue Racer

Last year I picked up a pair of Rogue Racers and have been pleasantly surprised. Over the last few months, I developed such confidence in them that I actually used them last week in the Wulfman Continental Divide Trail Race. I’ve done the race a couple times before, always running in my favorite trail shoe (Nike Zoom Trails), but this year I used the Rogue Racer. I had high expectations that I would run faster in the Montrails given that they are a bit lighter and more flexible than the Nikes. But that was not the case. I was a tad bit slower. I guess I am just getting old and a different shoe is not going to overcome the progression of age. Nevertheless, the Rogue Racers worked well. No blisters, no sprained ankles and at least they felt fast.

Running 2011 Wulfman in Nike Zoom Trail Shoes

Running 2011 Wulfman in Nike Zoom Trail Shoes

The pictures of the Rogue Racer are snatched from the Montrail website. The pictures running in the Wulfman race came from Butte’s Piss and Moan Runner’s website.

Running 2012 Wulfman in Montrail Rogue Racers

Running 2012 Wulfman in Montrail Rogue Racers

.

Fit and Feel

In my experience The Rogue Racer fits true to size. I’ve read that they run small and it is best to go up a half size. I have not found that to be the case. In some brands of shoes, I wear a 9.5 in others a 10. The size 10 Rogue Racer has plenty of room. I could probably even get by in a size 9.5.

They are a comfy cushioned shoe. I found I could tailor the fit easily with the laces. A good test of fit is how well does a shoe fit and hold your foot even when they are loosely laced. This is the first Montrail shoe I have tried where I felt that the upper actually gripped my foot and helped keep my foot centered over the sole. In rugged rocks or side hills where you can really tell how well a shoe fits, the Rogue Racers worked well and gave me adequate feeling of my shoes being a protective extension of my feet.

The Rogue Racers flex nicely under the ball of the foot; especially compared to other trail shoes that have a stiffer more protective rock plate. They have a rock plate that offers enough protection, yet does not unduly stiffen the shoe. About the only time the Rogue Racer feels clunky is running fast on a hard surface like a paved road. They feel a bit hard and slapy on road surfaces.

A Traditional High Heel Shoe

Although Montrail describes and advertises the Rogue Racer as a minimal neutral shoe, these are not a minimal shoe. They are also not a level or neutral shoe. They have a more traditional high cushioned heel. Even so, they were actually stable and not prone to ankle rolling as I would expect from such a high heel shoe. Perhaps that is testament to the proper fitting upper.

Traction

Montrail Rogue Racer Outsole

Montrail Rogue Racer Outsole

The outsole’s traction lugs are on the smallish side. They offer adequate traction on dry trails and rocks. On snow or in mud, they are a bit slippery. The less aggressive shallow lugged outsole is probably where Montrail saved some weight with these shoes. Design is a compromise. To get a lighter shoe, a bit of traction was sacrificed.

On dry loose pebbly surfaces, they also were a bit slippery as the sole materiel is rather hard. 

Weight

My size 10’s weigh in at 8.9 ounces. This is light for a Montrail brand shoe, but not as light as some of the more minimal trail shoes from New Balance or Salomon. They are slightly lighter than my Nike Zoom Trail and they feel lighter.

Cost

Retail is $115.00. You can find certain sizes and colors on Amazon and Ebay for about half that ($55.00).

Are They Suitable For the Ridge Run?

Unless the conditions are wet (muddy) or icy requiring a more aggressive outsole for traction, I think they would work fairly well.

Expect them to take a beating. They may not have much life in them after the Ridge Run.

If you are fairly nimble, they offer just enough protection and cushion. If your style on the downhills is to aggressively bulldoze down through the rocks without worry of where your feet land, then the Rogue Racer is probably not enough of a protective shoe for you.

Advertisements

About Bridger Ridge Run

The Bridger Ridge Run blog is an information portal for all those seeking to learn more about the Bridger Ridge Run event held every second Saturday of August in Bozeman Montana. This blog contains notifications about important registration dates and deadlines, history of the event, training advice and other stories and entertaining tidbits of information about the Bridger Ridge Run.
This entry was posted in Equipment, Shoe Reviews and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Montrail Rogue Racer Review

  1. Anonymous says:

    I enjoyed the Rouge racers for shorter and less technical trails than the ridge. In a training run last year from Bridger to the M my R Racers totally failed me. The foam under the heel compresed and never rebounded. Montrail was not cooperative in an exchange, informing me I was too heavy (#175)and on too rugged of terrain. Really a bummer, because the shoes felt great for a while…

    • Thanks for your comments and useful first-hand information regarding your experience running sections of the Ridge Run course with the Rogue Racers. Sorry to hear about Montrail’s stinginess on replacing your battered shoes.

      Yes the rocks and rugged terrain up there can really punish shoes.

      As the review concludes, “they may not have much life in them after the Ridge Run”. Sounds like you experienced that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s